By Tony Gonzalez, The Tennessean
Kids in Tennessee rank as the healthiest in the South - to the
surprise of even some state officials - in the latest state-by-state
comparison of the well-being of children.
The 2012 Kids Count Data Book,
released today by the Annie E. Casey Foundation, shows fewer teens
abusing alcohol and drugs, fewer kids living without health insurance
and fewer babies being born at low birth weights in the Volunteer State.
measures placed Tennessee 16th in the nation in children's health, one
place ahead of Virginia and far above other southern states. Measures
the state has struggled with in past Kids Count studies, including
childhood obesity, infant mortality and access to dental care, were not
Going beyond health, the foundation considered 16 total factors, and ranked the state at 36th overall for child well-being, the state's best placement to date and an improvement on last year's 39th-place ranking.
But the news wasn't all good.
study found economic hardship still rising, with one of four Tennessee
kids now living in poverty. And Tennessee lingered among the bottom 10
states for education. Three-fourths of fourth graders fail to read
proficiently, a decline that goes against a national trend of
"The ranking lets us know many of the things we're
doing now are heading in the right direction," said Michael Warren,
director of maternal and child health in the Tennessee Department of
Health. "I don't think anybody is happy with 36th, or even if you look
at our health ranking of 16, so I think we need to keep pushing."
reactions to the education category ranking of 42nd, based on dropout
rate, preschool attendance, and math and reading performance, ranged
from "awful" to "sad."
"Certainly, the education area is troubling
- the fact that 74 percent of fourth graders in Tennessee are not
reading proficiently," said Laura Speer, Kids Count coordinator with the
foundation. "That has long-term implications for educational attainment
for kids and how educated the workforce will be."
Tennessee scored higher than ever in the children's health category
in large part because the foundation eliminated infant mortality rate
and added health insurance coverage to the mix. That effectively swapped
out one of the state's worst areas for one of its best.
With only 5 percent of children living without health insurance, Tennessee surpassed the national average.
said the foundation changed measurements to focus on data proven to
predict well-being in the long run. She also said low birthweight and
infant mortality tell similar stories, creating a "double whammy" for
some states. Researchers chose to eliminate infant mortality from their
"Babies born at low birthweight are more likely
to struggle to meet the developmental milestones as they go through
their infant years," Speer said. "In that indicator, Tennessee is
lagging behind the rest of the country."
Tennessee has also seen
declining rates of child and teen death, attributable to good policies
regarding child safety restraints, life preservers in boats and use of
helmets, said Pam Brown, director of the Kids Count Project for the Tennessee Commission on Children and Youth.
"The fact that we've improved in all of these indices is significant," she said.
Education and poverty scores contained fewer surprises, officials said.
recession is still incredibly painful," said Mary Graham, president of
United Ways of Tennessee. "There's still a tremendous need for the
Graham said child advocates must resist pitting services against one another.
Hampshire, Massachusetts and Vermont ranked highest in overall child
well-being. Nevada, New Mexico and Mississippi ranked lowest.
How Tennessee ranks
The 2012 Kids Count survey ranks the health of Tennessee's infants,
children and teens. The state ranked among the bottom 10 states for many
years, but is now 36th overall. Here's how the state compares with the
Economic well-being: 38th
Family and community: 39th
More children are living in
poverty: 26 percent
Fewer fourth-graders read
proficiently: 74 percent
Fewer children do not have health insurance: 5 percent
More children live in single-parent families: 37 percent